Java.Collections.There is a special class for Enum. java.util.EnumSet. Why? Why were the authors not satisfied with HashSet or TreeSet?

🧠 EnumSet is a high-performance, memory-efficient set specifically optimized for use with enums.

Let’s dive into why the authors of Java created it instead of just using HashSet or TreeSet.


🚀 1. Enums have special properties

Enums in Java:

  • Have a finite number of possible values.
  • Are internally represented by integers (ordinal values).
  • Are known at compile-time.

So unlike arbitrary objects, we can represent enum sets as simple bit masks (i.e., BitSet-like structures).


🔥 2. EnumSet is much faster and lighter than HashSet

FeatureEnumSetHashSet<Enum>
Backing structureBit vector (array of longs)Hash table
Memory usage🟢 Very low🔴 Much higher
Performance🟢 O(1) for most ops🟠 O(1) average, but heavier
Nulls allowed?❌ No✅ Yes

Because of this:

  • EnumSet operations are blazing fast — faster than HashSet, TreeSet, or anything else.
  • It’s perfect for enum constants where you don’t need the overhead of hashing or comparison.

📦 3. TreeSet is unnecessary for Enums

  • All enums are inherently comparable (they implement Comparable by ordinal()).
  • So sorting is predefined, and the order is fixed.
  • Using TreeSet<Enum> would work, but it’s slower and overkill — O(log n) vs EnumSet’s O(1) operations.

So: EnumSet knows the order already, and doesn’t need a tree structure to maintain it.


✅ 4. Special Set operations

EnumSet also provides awesome factory methods:

EnumSet.of(Day.MONDAY, Day.WEDNESDAY)
EnumSet.range(Day.MONDAY, Day.FRIDAY)
EnumSet.allOf(Day.class)
EnumSet.noneOf(Day.class)

These methods are:

  • Type-safe ✅
  • Efficient ✅
  • Very readable ✅

You’d need manual, clunky work to do the same with HashSet or TreeSet.

📌 Why not just use HashSet?

LimitationHashSet
Memory waste (uses full hash map)
Slower (inserts and lookups)
No natural support for ranges or allOf
Accepts null (dangerous with enums)

🧠 TL;DR

EnumSet is like a turbocharged Set specifically for enum types.

  • It’s faster, safer, and leaner.
  • The Java authors created it to take full advantage of enum properties — and HashSet or TreeSet just couldn’t do that well enough.
This entry was posted in Без рубрики. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.